Connect with us

Compliance

Getting Agreement

A shareholders’ agreement is something many business owners overlook, yet it is a critical element of their business relationship.

Published

on

Entrepreneur signing a shareholders agreement

By creating a shareholders’ agreement the owners of a small, privately held company can prepare for events that have been the downfall of more than a few successful small businesses – death, divorce, bankruptcy, or the retirement of one of the owners.

A shareholders’ agreement is normally drawn up at the inception of a business, but if it isn’t in place from the start, it can always be concluded at a later stage. The shareholders’ agreement defines your shareholder relationships and how the company is managed. The relationship between shareholders is governed by the common law of the land, judgments of the courts and acts of Parliament (the most important of which is the Companies Act, Act No 61 of 1973, as amended) and the articles of association.

While you cannot contract out of the provisions acts of Parliament or judgments of the court, unless you have special permission, there is much you can, and should, agree upon in a shareholders’ agreement. It’s a complex document but, in general, the most important issues to address are:

  • The number of directors, the nomination and appointment of the directors and the number of votes each director has. Bear in mind that it is not possible for an agreement to deal with how directors must vote as they have a fiduciary duty towards the company and cannot be bound by an agreement;
  • Voting at shareholders’ meetings and, critically important, how minority shareholders are protected. One of the ways to ensure protection is to list those issues where the votes of the minority shareholders must be obtained before the company can proceed with the matter in question;
  • Buy/sell provisions, which control changes in the ownership of a company. This provision must be carefully thought through and a clause constructed which is suitable for the agreement in question. There are many interesting clauses such as the Texas Showdown clause, the Russian Roulette clause, the Armenian Handshake clause and others;
  • The agreement must deal with the way in which deadlocks will be handled. There are many ways such as the appointment of an independent director, mediation, arbitration, escalating the dispute, mutually assured destruction, a rotating chairman, court order dissolution or a trustee appointed by the court.
  • There are many other important clauses which must be inserted. If there is a death, a desire to exit, a dispute or a third party entering (or wishing to enter) the business, you will be only too grateful if you took the time and effort, and spent the money, to have an expert attorney prepare a carefully constructed and thought-through shareholders’ agreement. Remember that the shareholders’ agreement is a living and breathing document and should be reviewed on a regular basis.
  • Many shareholders’ agreements provide that a party can have the articles of association amended to comply with the agreement. This is not done frequently, however, because the memorandum and articles of association are a public document and the parties often do not want issues dealt with in the shareholders’ agreement to be available to the public and, more importantly, to competitors. So the agreement remains binding on the parties, but not on third parties who are only bound if the provisions of the shareholders’ agreement have been incorporated in the articles of association or the content of the shareholders’ agreement has been brought to their attention.

What Are Buy-Sell Provisions?

Buy/sell provisions control when and how shares in a company can be bought and sold, and are included in a shareholders’ agreement or a buy/sell agreement that controls the following business decisions:

  • Who can buy a departing shareholder’s stock (this may include outsiders or be limited to other shareholders)
  • What events will trigger a buyout
  • What price will be paid for a shareholder’s interest in the corporation
  • Among the many types of buy/sell provisions in common use are the “Russian Roulette”, the “Texas Showdown”, the “Armenian Handshake” and more.

The Russian Roulette buy/sell provides inherent advantage to wealthy shareholders even if they own a minority interest. With a Russian Roulette clause, any shareholder can offer to buy another’s shareholding. The responding shareholder must either accept the offer or make a counter offer to buy at an even higher price, but cannot do nothing.

Others, such as the Armenian Handshake, are better at protecting minority and weaker shareholders from abuse by majority and wealthier shareholders. The Armenian Handshake provides that no shareholder is allowed to directly or indirectly accept or extract any form of compensation from the company without either sharing it on a pro rata basis with the other shareholders in proportion to their shareholdings, or obtaining consent from all the other shareholders to retain it themselves. It applies to salary, dividends and consulting fees.

In the Texas Showdown, the selling shareholder sets a price per share for their shares and claims. The remaining shareholders respond with an election to buy or to sell their shares in and claims against the company to the selling shareholder. If the remaining shareholders decline to buy the selling shareholder’s shares and claims, they are required to sell their shares and claims to the exiting shareholder. Obviously, the advantage of this clause is that it forces the selling shareholder to set a fair and reasonable price.

Compliance

Innovative Business Solutions And Compliance

Compliance with certification is a strong way to demonstrate that you are managing your business proactively.

Published

on

thinking-out-the-box

As a business owner, you are probably aware of where your business could improve. Sometimes a business owner would like to improve their business but is not sure how to begin. Therefore, it is of the utmost importance to develop an environment which will foster innovation and create key steps to improve your business while simultaneously trying to comply with all of the necessary legalities.

It is important for an entrepreneur to assess their situation first. Most business owners will ask the question why? Why can’t everyone will follow the same steps to success. Every business is different and unique, therefore, before you start making changes within your business, it is a good idea to make sure you have a full understanding of the factors affecting your business success and whether you are complying with necessary legalities.

Compliance may actually improve performance by giving your business a competitive edge. Legal compliance can assist you with improving your customer relations, enhancing your reputation and most importantly avoiding the cost of legal proceedings.

There’s this saying, ‘What gets measured gets improved’ explains Charles Gaudet, founder and CEO of Predictable Profits, a consulting firm that offers advanced marketing techniques to entrepreneurs who are passionate about expanding their small businesses.

Related: Compliance For Entrepreneurs

Here are a few strategies that you can use to make your business more profitable in the future.

Innovative Marketing solutions

For every business owner, marketing is an important tool to improve their businesses. You may think that you are missing an opportunity if you don’t jump right attracting customers with some type of marketing message.

However, as quoted by John Rampton ‘’one of the best things you can do to achieve growth is to slow down and spend time studying the trends.” What does this mean?  While rushing into marketing your product you tend to forget certain details, and once it is out in the public its difficult to forget or to undo. Therefore, its very important to research the market and consumer trends before launching anything.

This becomes very important when you consider the potential risk to your business for the infringement of another product, which is confusingly similar to your product. You also do not wish to be guilty of using a similar brand name, slogan or logo as one of your competitors.  Therefore, before you set out your personalised solutions when designing ads and directing messages to consumers ensure you are not infringing on anyone else’s rights as this will likely lead to expensive legal costs for your business.  

Compliance Breeds Confidence

It is important to remember that clients are concerned whether suppliers are properly compliant. Compliance with certification is a strong way to demonstrate that you are managing your business proactively and that the money a customer will spend i.t.o. buying your goods or services, is in safe hands. Conversely a failure in compliance can, as well as exposing you to the risk of regulatory sanctions, severely damage your business’ credibility.

Related: Why HR Legislation Compliance Can Curb Business Failure

For example, in the financial services industry there is an increasing requirement to demonstrate strong security to both external auditors and prospective customers.

With regulation that you feel is of no value, determine how to satisfy the requirements with the minimum effort necessary. Do, however, double check that you are not missing out on a benefit that may be rewarding for your business.

In conclusion, it is important to note when improving your business one always need to act in accordance with the correct laws and procedures. Therefore, if a company is embracing the difficult task of being compliant, I recommend using this as a competitive weapon to improve your business. It just might end up making you and your team better which is usually rewarded with more business.

Continue Reading

Compliance

Policies and Procedures – A Critical Business Support Tool

No longer just an administrative burden, policies and procedures are an essential business support tool in a complex business environment.

Neil Summers

Published

on

policies-and-procedures

In South Africa, SMMEs account for more than 70% of the overall employment rate. It’s critical, therefore, that SMMEs maintain both stability and growth concurrently – our country’s economic development depends on it. However, the tension between stability and growth must be managed, particularly in today’s complex regulatory environment with its ever-increasing compliance requirements.

Smaller organisations often consider policy creation, management and distribution as an administrative burden. Fortunately, growing numbers of small business owners and managers are realising that accessible and clearly-written policies and procedures are essential to business success.

Companies that create, manage and distribute clear policies and procedures reap significant business benefits, some of which are highlighted below.

Consistency and Stability

Clear policies and procedures ensure that staff and management adhere to specific ways of working, minimising time spent on analysis and interpretation, while creating consistency and stability across the organisation.

Guidance

Policies and procedures allow new hires to onboard quickly, while ensuring they adhere to standard practices and controls.

Related: Your Business Needs a Corporate Governance Policy

Safety

Health and safety policies not only protect staff, but also visiting clients and stakeholders.

Limitations

compliance

It is important to define boundaries around a position or role. Employees must know and understand their respective responsibilities.

Cost Efficiencies

Standardised procedures lead to cost efficiencies from both time and resource perspectives.

Geographic Spread

Policies and procedures allow organisations working in different areas to develop a uniform approach to business processes which, in turn, supports internal staff transfer when and if required.

Compliance

Businesses operate in a highly regulated environment. Proof of compliance is not only required in terms of the regulatory environment, but also in terms of risk management and governance. SMMEs do not always appreciate the value demonstrable risk management and governance structures can have, albeit as intangible assets. These structures enhance the oversight role of any business, providing more developed and sustainable business strategies. An additional benefit is the ability to manage liability arising from negligence or malpractice suits. It is no longer enough just to have a policy in place though – distribution and access must be shown.

Related: HR Management Basics For The Small Business

Learning Culture

SMMEs can create and develop a learning culture depending on the availability and distribution of policies and procedures. Tests and assessments linked to specific policies confirm knowledge transfer, formalising both learning and the eligibility to complete tasks.

Given the ever-increasing complexity and competitiveness of business today, policies and procedures provide the parameters and guidelines of business operations, enhancing efficiencies, increasing value and promoting professionalism. Policies and procedures are no longer just an administrative function, they are a critical tool for business success.

Continue Reading

Compliance

4 Vital Differences Between King III And King IV™ On Corporate Governance

Ilana Steyn, unpacks some of the most significant differences between the Institute of Directors in Southern Africa’s (IoDSA) latest report on corporate governance, the King IV Report, and its former version, King III.

Ilana Steyn

Published

on

corporate-governance-2018-policies

April 2018 marks a year since the effective date of the IoDSA’s (Institute of Directors in Southern Africa) latest report, the King IV Report on Corporate Governance ™ (King IV™), on effective and ethical corporate governance.

What is the King Report?

If you’re not familiar with the King Reports: it’s a series of reports that translate international standards and big-time happenings on corporate governance into set of local principles. Each new Report replaces the former.

The aim of the King Report is to set up actionable principles for South African company leadership to act as modern, good corporate citizens.

It also ensures those in leadership positions act in the best interest of the company and all parties influenced by the company. The first Report, King I, published in 1994, and was the first officiated document of its kind in South Africa.

Related: How To Say ‘No’ At Work (Infographic)

Why is it useful to my business?

The Report also promotes transparency within your company’s leadership to ensure transgressions aren’t hidden that will eventually damage the company. The Report also ensure blunders can be evaluated, found and corrected ASAP. Today, its mandatory for all JSE listed companies to implement the Report into their company policy.

If you’re a smaller business or a non-profit, you can comply with the Report voluntarily; by applying the principles you’re essentially ensuring the long-term sustainability and survival of the business.

It also helps that create a healthy corporate culture and when your business’s foundation is healthy, growth is unthreatened.

If you haven’t applied any of the former Reports in your business, you’re in luck; King IV™ is the simplest, and seemingly the most practical, Report in the family of four reports.

Why was King IV™ needed?

Companies, especially smaller businesses, often struggled to apply the King III due to its long-winded structure.

King IV™ was needed because King III, published in 2009, was out-dated in terms of present-day concerns like technological advances, the increased need for online transparency, long-term resource sustainability and information security.

Here’s the rundown of the most significant differences between King IV™ and King III.

1. King IV’s™ structure is much simpler to apply

While King III did a good job of summarising the extensive scope of effective and ethical governance into 75 principles, the Report still lacked clear guidance on real-world application.

Ensuring the effective incorporation of all 75 vague, ethical principles was too exhaustive for most companies to implement, monitor and account for.

That’s why King IV™ took a different structural approach. King IV™ boiled good corporate governance down to 17 simplified principles, each supplemented with various recommended practices to make it easier for smaller companies to implement the principles within their day-to-day running.

2. King IV™ spotlights practical implementation

King III lists multiple ethical principles and then commands companies to explain how their management and actions honour those principles. Unfortunately this meant companies approached it like a mindless compliance checklist.

King IV™ also states principles, but more importantly, requires organisations to actively report on the implementation of the recommended practices thereof.

Mervyn King, the chair of the King Committee, dubs this the shift from a “apply OR explain” mentality to a “apply AND explain” mentality. The Report also allows organisations to report on alterative-implemented practices – provided they support and advance the principle.

Related: How to Make Your Business Model Go the Distance

To make the application simpler to grasp, King IV™ clearly differentiates between the long-term Outcomes, the ethical Principles and the recommended Practices. Essentially the new structure and its requirements mean companies have to engage in thoughtful implementation and reporting of those practices.

3. King IV™ is inclusive to more than just large companies

After King III, there was a significant demand for the inclusivity of smaller businesses, and governmental or non-profit organizations in the King Report.

Consequently, King IV™ dedicates an entire supplement chapter to guiding municipalities; non-profit organizations; retirement funds; small and medium enterprises and state-owned entities in the implementation of the Report.

Also, where King III used terms like “companies” and “boards”, King IV™ very purposefully uses more inclusive terms like “governing bodies” and “organizations” throughout the report. It’s clear that King IV™ aims to move the principles on good corporate governance into real-world action – for all organisations.

4. Difference 3: King IV™ pushes for more accountability, transparency and reporting

What King IV™ does quite differently from King III, is recommending the application of its principles within set timelines, reports and committees within it’s recommended practices.

King IV™ strongly propagates transparency, the delegation of responsibility and the implementation of accountability by putting pen to paper in term of officiated aims, bodies responsible for those aims and the provisions of consistent reports.

Take leadership as an example, where King III would just stipulate what being a good leader means, King IV™ advises you to set goals, delegate responsibility and evaluate progress through reports and accountability.

An example would be to set up a committee, consisting of lower management levels, with clearly identifiable responsibilities and then to measure their progress via reports. It comes down to the ignorance no longer being a valid excuse. Directors should be aware of all issues within your company.

Directors should take responsibility for everything that happens within their organisation – you can’t plead innocence on the grounds of not knowing. There should rather be reports in place to identify and uncover any discrepancies early on.

Essentially, where King III lacks in the aim of ensuring the actualization of good corporate citizenship, King IV™ steps up the game.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

SPOTLIGHT

Advertisement

Recent Posts

Follow Us

Entrepreneur-Newsletters
*
We respect your privacy. 
* indicates required.
Advertisement

Trending