Connect with us

Franchisee Advice

How To Avoid And Resolve Shareholder Disputes

Shareholder agreements are not fool-proof; disputes still arise. Here’s how to resolve clashes before they erode your business.

Monisha Prem

Published

on

disposal-of-shares

In our previous discussion we explored the importance of establishing a foundation to any equity sharing relationship. In this follow-up we look at specific provisions of the shareholders’ agreement and other methods to avoid and resolve disputes.

Crucial Provisions

Capital Contribution. Clearly state how much each shareholder has contributed, whether the capital is applied as equity or shareholders’ loan and terms of repayment, if any.

Also, determine how to apply and repay future shareholders’ loans, and any arrangements when raising capital in the future from shareholders and third parties. In some instances shareholders’ will be required to contribute monies, security, or sureties.

Related: Understanding Shareholder Agreements

Minority and Majority Shareholder Perspectives

Minority shareholders look for protection in quorums to start meetings, vote at meetings and pass resolutions, and the right to appoint directors on the board.

This ensures complete and autonomous representation of shareholders and reduces the risk of ambushing or bullying tactics by majority shareholders. Minority shareholders also look for protection on disposal of shares in the Tag Along principle – if a majority is selling, the minority has the right to join the deal.

Similarly, majority shareholders look for protection in adequate board representations and quorums. Critical to majority shareholders is pro rata participation of all shareholders and that the majority is not required to carry the burden of financial or administrative support or pro rata dilution if the business issues new shares.

Similar to the minority, the majority is protected during disposal of shares in the Drag Along principle — if a third party wishes to buy all the shares of the business and the majority wishes to sell, the minority is forced to sell.

disposal-of-shares

Disposal of Shares

Disposal of shares includes sale to a third party, disposal on death or incapacity, or retirement as an exit strategy. Shareholders often dread the introduction of heirs and beneficiaries to a deceased estate for multiple reasons, including the lack of ability to strategically influence the business.

Mechanisms in managing disposal of shares for the Shareholders’ Agreement may include pre-emptive rights or first option rights to remaining shareholders for voluntary and involuntary sale; or introducing a succession plan for retirement; or establishing a call/put option to the business on retirement dates.

Related: How To BootStrap Your Business With Funding From Your Shareholders

Resolve Shareholder Disputes

Shareholders’ Agreement. The Companies Act and Memorandum of Incorporation adequately cover the basic terms of engagement including powers, duties and related limitations. It is not a requirement of law to execute a Shareholders’ Agreement, however, it is recommended.

Negotiation and Mediation

The first step in resolving a dispute is for parties to commit to avoiding approaching the courts. To this end, the Shareholders’ Agreement should clearly state that all parties will negotiate, and if required appoint an appropriate independent third party, such as an expert in the field of the dispute, to mediate the negotiation.

The Companies Tribunal

This tribunal is established in terms of the Companies Act and is a voluntary resolution of disputes as an alternate to formal arbitration or litigation. Its mandates adjudicate any matter regulated by the Companies Act.

Formal Arbitration

If the negotiation and mediation is unsuccessful the parties can approach an arbitration body, such as the Arbitration Foundation of South Africa, or submit a complaint to the Companies and Intellectual Property Commission.

The point of arbitration is to offer an alternate to resolving disputes in court. The rules and costs of this route must be considered.

Related: How To Fund Your Business By Taking On New Shareholders

Litigation

The Shareholders’ Agreement must allow for any party to approach the courts if alternate resolution is unsuccessful or if a matter is considered pressing, such as an application for an urgent interdict.

As with arbitration, shareholders must consider the cost implications of this remedy.

A shareholder cannot be dismissed nor resign voluntarily or involuntarily. The only way a shareholder may exit the business is if she sells, donates or bequeaths her shares to a third party, the remaining shareholders or the company; alternatively if the company liquidates.

It is critical that two important aspects of preventing or resolving shareholders’ disputes are implemented at the outset of a start-up business: Ensure that this is the right match for you and your business, and be absolutely certain about when and how to exit if the arrangement doesn’t work.

Monisha is a corporate advisor, admitted attorney at M. Prem Inc, and author with over 14 years deal-making experience. Monisha litigated for several years before joining an investment banking firm specialising in mergers and acquisitions. Monisha has owned and operated several businesses, is passionate about business development, commercial and corporate law.

Franchisee Advice

6 Top Tips For Reading Management Accounts

There is a golden key that reveals the secret of whether your business will survive and thrive. It is keeping tabs on the figures that summarise the strength of your business – your monthly management accounts.

Richard Mukheibir

Published

on

accounts-management

There is a golden key that reveals the secret of whether your business will survive and thrive. It is not the brilliance of your business concept. It is not your talent for talking clients to sign on the dotted line. It is keeping tabs on the figures that summarise the strength of your business – your monthly management accounts.

Related: 6 Things You Need To Know About Profit And Cashflow

Many entrepreneurs are usually more interested in operations and find product development or sales much more enjoyable than catching up on accounts. I sympathise – I’m one of them! So if you feel the same way, my top tip is always to make sure that you partner with or employ someone who can oversee the finances for you.

But that does not mean you can let the figure boffins and the finances take care of themselves. To function properly in your business, you need to know the outcome of your sales and development strategies – and the story of that is told in your management accounts.

 If you never look at your management accounts, it is like blinding yourself in one eye. It means you risk being literally blindsided by a big surprise, whether it is heading for a significant loss or being confronted by an unexpected provisional tax payment.

Here is how Engela van Loggerenberg, our Group Financial Manager, puts management accounts in perspective for our new franchisees. She urges them to focus on six key areas:

  1. Priorities: Management accounts can help you pinpoint areas that you need to prioritise, whether to capitalise on growth or because they are not performing as well as you hoped.
  2. Strength: All businesses aim to grow their assets over time and the balance sheet in your management accounts will reflect whether and how you are achieving that.
  3. Control: A strong balance sheet is one that shows you have your business liabilities well controlled. The key marker here is your current liquidity ratio, which results from dividing your current assets by your current liabilities. To keep your business healthy, always aim to keep this ratio at least 2:1.
  4. Revenue: Ideally, you want to see your revenue grow month by month. Check your income statement both for the trend in actual revenue and also for actual against budgeted revenue to check how well your strategies are delivering results.
  5. Profitability: Of course, revenue is not the same as profitability. You need to know your gross profit – the basic figure of your sales less the cost of those goods – and net profit, which also deducts a range of other expenses including taxes. Track the percentage of these two profit figures as well as the actual cash amount they represent to keep a check on whether your costs are creeping up too high.
  6. Finance: Most businesses at some point want to finance their growth by borrowing from a bank. A set of well-regulated management accounts is a prerequisite to obtaining finance.

Your management accounts do not have to be particularly complicated to give you these vital pointers – and if you are figure-shy, the more straightforward the better.

The important thing, though, is that you do not allow yourself to be too scared to ask if there is something which is not clear to you. That is the way to keep control of this key to your business fortunes and to keep building your business from strength to strength.

Related: 7 Things Every Entrepreneur Should Know About Managing Cash In The Business

Continue Reading

Company Posts

A Three-Pronged Approach To Franchise Success

Danie Nel, head of business development for Cash Crusaders franchising, says the brand’s success over the past 22 years 
is attributed to the sentiment that “a profitable franchisee 
is a happy franchisee.”

Nedbank Franchising

Published

on

danie-nel-cash-crusaders

What is your current footprint?

220 Stores. We’re looking to increase that number by another 20 stores for the 2018 financial year, which will then bring us to a total of 240 stores. Depending on the economy, we’re looking to grow our footprint even more to around 300 to 350 stores nationwide in the near future.

What are some of your brand’s biggest achievements that other franchises can learn from?

Our ability to read the retail market and innovate to stay ahead of times. We have recently launched an online platform where customers can sell their goods or borrow money — all online. This was a first for online retailing. One other achievement that I would wish to highlight is the launch of our mobile phone range, Doogee, exclusive to Cash Crusaders. Personally, having the honour of opening our 200th store was a tremendous achievement.

Franchisor involvement has also played a big role in the success of the organisation. Our CEO Sean Stegmann and other senior managers are as much involved in the business as any other operations manager or operator.

There is simply no ‘ivory tower’ management in our business and it makes a huge difference.

Related: How Sorbet Franchisee Kate Holahan Is Nailing Success By Following Her Dream

What are some of the challenges you’ve encountered and how have you overcome these?

Some of our daily challenges include securing a premises at a favourable rental and securing a franchisee with sufficient unencumbered capital, who is credit- worthy. Once the store is open, cash flow management and stock procurement is key.

In addition to this, it’s a challenge to achieve profitability immediately and to meet franchisee expectations. It’s also vital to ensure superb customer service and to retain those customers in the current retail and economic climate. I would say that our single biggest challenge is to retain and to build our customer base.

What attracts franchisees to Cash Crusaders?

Our unique retail model that allows for multiple streams of income through one business. These three profit centres include: New goods (variety of imported quality goods), second-hand goods (which we buy directly from the public, either through customers coming directly to our stores, or via our house-buy system offered by some of our stores) and secured lending (a financial service where customers can borrow money against valuables, determined at store level, and the loan is repaid within 30 days — or the contract is renewed for another 30 days with interest and service fees charged).

Why is it important for successful franchises such as yours to have a strong banking partner and how does it benefit both the franchisor and the franchisee?

Gone are the days where you just got a deposit book or cheque book and a little business loan from your bank. Banking has become more sophisticated and the technology that the bank offers is as important as its service, making life for both the franchisee and the franchisor easier on a day-to-day basis.

Continue Reading

Franchisee Advice

5 S-Words Make Your Store Site Pay For Itself

Richard Mukheibir, CEO of Cash Converters recently addressed delegates at the FASA (Franchise Association of SA) conference on the topic of choosing the best location for their business. He spoke about the 5-S technique to assist business owners with deciding which premises is best suited for their business.

Richard Mukheibir

Published

on

retail-franchise

The combination of continuing trading uncertainty in South Africa and the new financial year for many businesses can add up to carefully reviewing costs – including leases on premises. Choosing a site to set up or relocate your business can be just as stressful as deciding where to buy a house – and just as fundamental to its health, finances and sustainability, says Richard Mukheibir, CEO of Cash Converters.

This is not the time to snap up the property with the cheapest rental as that might turn out to be something you regret in the long run. Nor is it the time to be dazzled by the swankiest premises you can find. The potential for bragging rights could turn out to be poor value for money.

“This is a time for your head to rule your heart regardless of the industry you trade in.” he says.

The real-estate mantra of “location, location, location” works just as effectively in commercial as it does in private property but you will often be looking for rather different factors. Mukheibir shares his 5-S technique to help you begin narrowing down the areas where you will consider locating your business – first at the macro level, focus in further to the meso level, then look more closely at the micro level before you start weighing up specific sites.

1. Strategy

Remind yourself of the medium and long-term strategies you have developed for your business. Keep your understanding of your business’s customers, purpose and growth prospects top of mind when you are selecting the areas where you will start looking for sites.

Related: Effective Ways To Bring Customers To Your Door

2. Scope

Within those areas, redline any sections where you feel the competition from other businesses will detract from your potential to grow your market. Greenline areas where there are good synergies between the people who live or work there and the demographic that you have identified as your target market.

3. Synergy

Make sure there is clearly a good pool of potential customers for you – size definitely matters when it comes to ensuring that there are plenty of customers available to you. Look specifically for facilities that cater for the kind of customers you want to attract. Sports stores benefit from being close to schools and tertiary colleges, for example.

4. Sight

Although many businesses now have an online element, most still benefit from attracting customers to walk through the door. For your premises to be a good fit for your business, you should be located in plain sight and ensure that your ability to market yourself locally through signage and lamp-post posters is not restricted by local bylaws.

Related: FASA Establishes Industry Specific Food Franchise Forum

5. Security

You will attract and retain good customers and staff if they feel they’re secure in the area. This perception includes factors such as easy, safe parking and a welcoming environment.

“Making a success of your business is not just about the product or your branding,” says Mukheibir. “It can be as fundamental as finding a site that ends up paying for itself. To do this, it must offer you a well-calculated gap in the market where the strong demand for the product or service that your business offers ensures sales and profit. If you have considered all these steps carefully, you will never worry about making rent and wages payment again.”

Continue Reading
Advertisement

SPOTLIGHT

Advertisement

Recent Posts

Follow Us

Entrepreneur-Newsletters
*
We respect your privacy. 
* indicates required.
Advertisement

Trending